Compensation packages reflect individual performance and are also closely tied to the institution’s financial health, regulatory requirements, and broader economic trends.

For industry leaders, staying informed about these trends is necessary for making strategic decisions and maintaining a competitive edge.

Leveraging Industry Data for Strategic Advantage

In 2023, the commercial banking sector faced several unanticipated challenges, including a high inflationary environment, rising interest rates, and multiple bank failures. These events significantly impacted executive compensation across the industry.

Industry data by American Banker reveals that in 2021, median total compensation for bank CEOs increased significantly by 21.5%, driven by strong financial performance and a surge in annual incentive bonuses.

The following year, compensation continued to rise, albeit at a more moderate 7%, as the tight labor market influenced target compensation levels.

However, 2023 presented a different scenario, with median total compensation decreasing by 6.6%. This decline was the first since the pandemic’s onset in 2020 and was mainly due to the economic turbulence that characterized the year.

Understanding the Impact of Economic Factors on Compensation

Executive compensation in the commercial banking industry is highly sensitive to economic factors. In 2023, the market volatility, coupled with rising interest rates and the fallout from bank failures, led to a decline in financial performance across the sector. As a result, CEO incentive payouts were reduced, aligning with the lower financial performance metrics of the year.

Bonuses, a critical component of executive compensation, were particularly affected. Many banks set their target goals early in the year, before the significant disruptions caused by the failures of banks like SVB and First Republic. These events triggered a shift in industry strategy, focusing more on asset and deposit gathering than loan issuance, which impacted stock prices and, subsequently, the ability to meet set targets.

Despite these challenges, some boards used discretion in adjusting bonuses, considering factors outside management’s control, such as the FDIC’s unique assessment and the overall regulatory environment.

The Role of Qualitative Metrics in Compensation Decisions

In recent years, qualitative metrics have been increasingly emphasized in determining executive bonuses. These metrics, which often account for around 20% of a bonus, are designed to assess performance in areas that may not be easily quantifiable but are nonetheless critical to the bank’s success.

What are competitive salaries in Commercial Banking and Private Wealth? Read our salary report now. Available via instant download.

Boards are becoming more adept at ensuring these qualitative assessments are objective and measurable, reducing subjectivity in compensation decisions. By setting clear, strategic goals at the beginning of the year, banks can better align their compensation packages with long-term performance objectives, even amid economic uncertainty.

Conclusion: Staying Competitive in a Challenging Environment

For commercial banking professionals, understanding these compensation trends is not just about staying informed—it’s about staying competitive. By leveraging data and insights into industry practices, you can better navigate the complexities of executive compensation, ensuring your institution remains attractive to top talent while aligning pay with performance.

As the industry faces economic challenges, strategic compensation decisions will be vital to maintaining financial stability and achieving long-term success.

At The Anderson Search Group, we understand commercial banks’ unique challenges and aspirations. Contact us today if you’re ready to explore new possibilities and take your practice to the next level.